If you’re in the market for an awesome BBQ grill, then Broil King vs. Weber are two big brands you’ve probably considered. But how do these two epic grilling companies match up when going head to head? (Or, grill to grill?)
Can Broil King complete with the undisputed American grilling champ, Weber? We’re about to analyze every possible difference between these two grilling behemoths so you can choose the perfect BBQ grill for your situation. Let’s begin!
- Weber vs Broil King: The Ultimate Comparison
- Weber vs Broil King Grill Product Comparisons
- Weber vs Broil King – Which One Should You Buy for Your Next BBQ?
- Do You Agree?
Weber vs Broil King: The Ultimate Comparison
|Feature||Weber’s Grade||Broil King’s Grade|
|Overall Product Comparison||A||A-|
We tested and researched both brands for build quality, trustworthiness, shipping, warranties, and prices to compare Broil King and Weber. Then, we put several of their best-selling grills head to head to see which ones came out on top.
When reviewing Broil King vs Weber grills, the first variable to consider is the grill build quality. Name recognition doesn’t mean anything if the gas grills can’t produce delicious and savory barbequed goods!
How do these two BBQ grill brands stack up where it matters? We’ve analyzed countless Weber gas grills and Broil King gas grills to give you an excellent rundown. Here’s what we’ve learned.
Broil King Build Quality
When you fire up your first steak, burger, or sausage using a Broil King, you’ll notice the build is solid and sturdy.
That’s because all Broil King gas barbeque grills are manufactured by North American workers in their North American locations. Broil King has manufacturing locations in Dickson, Tennessee; Huntington, Indiana; and Waterloo, Ontario.
Most components that make up a Broil King gas grill are fabricated by North American craftspeople using North American steel. Broil King proudly states that their grill cook box, shelves, and steel carts are 100% North American made.
Broil King gas grills aren’t made entirely in the US, though. If you read between the lines, some of Broil King’s grill components seem to be sourced globally.
Weber Build Quality
The legendary grill master who founded Weber, George A. Stephen, always knew that the now-famous rounded cooking bowl shape was a genius design for barbequing steaks, burgers, and hotdogs. George crafted his first epic Weber grill way back in 1952.
But how do the build quality and manufacturing processes hold up after all these years?
Today, Weber grills are engineered by its US-based team in the official Chicago Weber headquarters. Their innovative grill designs then head to Huntley, Illinois, for American-based manufacturing.
Comparing Broil King vs Weber, Weber grills are as solid and well-made as Broil King grills.
After experimenting with many Weber grills, I can say that the construction is reliable, and their grills are built to last. However, like Broil King, Weber also admits that some BBQ grill components are sourced globally.
Weber vs Broil King – Which Has a Better Quality Build Overall?
I think both Broil King and Weber offer excellent build quality and value. While Weber and Broil King manufacture many of their grill components in North America, they also rely on globally sourced grill components to build and deploy their grill lines.
For these reasons, and after experimenting with grills from both brands, I believe they are of comparable build quality. When you touch and feel the grills from Broil King vs Weber, you can tell that the grills are built with love and quality components.
However, when you dive deeper into the real customer reviews from Weber vs Broil King, you’ll discover that one of the two grilling brands comes out on top. Which grilling manufacturer wins? Broil King vs Weber? Continue reading to discover our findings!
Weber vs Broil King Build Quality Insights
- Broil King and Weber use US-based manufacturing
- Broil King and Weber use some globally-sourced components
- Broil King and Weber offer excellent build quality
- Broil King and Weber offer generous warranties
Trustworthiness and Reviews
One of the best ways to compare Broil King vs Weber is by reading real customer reviews. We can compare technical details and comparable build quality for eons. But what do real customers, grillmasters, and grill connoisseurs have to say?
We’ve analyzed dozens (if not hundreds) of real customer reviews on several marketplaces and are ready to share our findings.
Weber vs Broil King – Which Has Better Reviews Overall?
I grade Broil King with an A- trustworthiness grade. I give Weber an A+ trustworthiness grade. I love both brands. However, I think Weber does more for their customers than Broil King.
The defining component that makes Weber the better choice regarding trustworthiness is their superior number of 5-star reviews. When weighing Broil King vs. Weber, it seems evident that Broil King earns fewer 5-star reviews.
When you browse the top BBQ grill and e-commerce retailers like Amazon, Walmart, and Target, you’ll notice that Weber reviews also outnumber Broil King reviews 100 to 1 or even 1,000 to 1.
Even though Weber has more reviews than Broil King, it seems Weber also has fewer negative reviews.
Therefore, while Broil King makes a fabulous BBQ grill, Weber has superior trustworthiness and better reviews overall.
Weber vs Broil King Trustworthiness Insights:
- Broil King and Weber both have excellent reviews, and many diehard grilling fans rave about each brand
- Weber arguably has better reviews overall
- Weber seems much more popular, as there are many more reviews for Weber products than for Broil King’s.
Both Weber and Broil King gas grills are easy to snag on Amazon, which may offer free (or cheap) shipping. Let’s take a closer look at how the shipping deals compare for Broil King vs Weber.
Broil King Shipping
Broil King doesn’t ship any of their BBQ grills to consumers. Instead, Broil King relies on third-party merchants to sell and ship their BBQ grills.
You can find Broil King on Amazon for online purchases. One benefit of ordering through Amazon is that they often have free shipping deals. However, it doesn’t just stop with shipping. When you get your grill through Amazon, you can also get a free entryway delivery and a free professional assembly with your purchase.
So, you can get a great deal on Broil King products at Amazon, and shipping is usually free.
Most Weber products ship for free from Amazon, and, like Broil King’s grills, most of them come with free professional assembly and entryway delivery.
So, ultimately, both Weber and Broil King have equally great shipping deals, especially when you purchase your grill through Amazon.
One of the most frustrating things is when you try to fire up your grill and hear an annoying clicking sound. The BBQ click of death. Oh no! Your grill’s burner is busted!
Luckily, both Weber and Broil King offer outstanding warranties compared to other BBQ grill manufacturers. No more trying to tussle and fix your BBQ grill with a rusty ole Buck knife!
That’s because Weber offers a generous 10-year warranty on many of their grill components. However, some of their grill components only have a 5-year or 2-year warranty.
Broil King also offers generous 10-year and limited-lifetime warranties on many grilling components. But, just like with Weber, some grill components (like side-burners, stainless-steel components, and paint) have a much shorter warranty span of only 2 to 5 years.
Regardless of which grill you choose, always double-check your model at the time of purchase for full warranty information.
I’ve reviewed the pricing points for Broil King vs Weber closely. Many grilling gurus automatically assume that Weber is more expensive. However, the pricing is closer than most grillers think. I rank both Weber and Broil King as affordable and high-value. Maybe Weber is a tad more expensive, but not by much.
Let’s quickly look at some affordable cooking and grilling options from Broil King vs Weber.
Broil King doesn’t have many cheaper grills in the $100 to $200 range. However, they have a nifty portable stove that I like. Take this Broil King Porta-Chef Portable Stove as an example. Here’s a low-cost portable stove from Broil King that will only run you a few hundred bucks – or less.
Weber has some fantastic affordable grills, like their famous Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill or the Weber 741001 Original Kettle Charcoal Grill. Both options from Weber cost around $100 to $200. That’s BBQ grilling on a budget!
The 3 products from Broil King vs Weber:
Broil King vs Weber Pricing Insights:
- Weber seems to have more affordable grills in the $100 – $200 range
- When it comes to the high-end grills, Weber seems to be slightly more expensive than Broil King
Weber vs Broil King Grill Product Comparisons
Let’s also compare some of the entry-level Broil King vs Weber grills head to head! Then, we’ll compare two of the premium high-end grills from Broil King vs Weber.
Entry-Level Grill Showdown #1 – Broil King Signet 320 vs Weber Spirit E-310
- Liquid propane gas grill
- 635 square inches of cooking space
- 40,000 BTUs
- 134 pounds
- Cast-iron cooking grates
- Stainless steel side shelves
- More Cooking Space
- More expensive than Weber
- Some customers complain about damage from shipping
- Liquid propane gas grill
- 529 square-inches of cooking space
- 32,000 BTUs
- 130 pounds
- Porcelain-enameled, cast-iron cooking grates
- Stainless steel side tables
- Less expensive
- Ratings are overall very high
- Long-lasting and durable
- Less cooking space
- Less powerful
How do two of the most popular entry-level gas grills from Broil King vs Weber stack up? Let’s find out!
Broil King Signet 320
The Broil King Signet 320 cast aluminum grill is one of my favorite gas grills from Broil King. Many of the reviewers swear that this is one of the best gas grills on the market – period.
With three stainless steel burners and 40,000 BTUs of power, you have plenty of cooking juice and flexibility to fire up your steaks, burgers, and sausages with heat to spare. Whether you want to cook your food fast or chillax on your backyard hammock while you slowly fire up some BBQ chicken, the Broil King Signet 320 accommodates.
The Broil King Signet 320 has excellent heat distribution due to the stainless steel Flav-R-Wave Cooking System and cast iron grates. Flav-R-Wave also adds serious flavor to your meats by catching any drippings and then letting the savory flavors vaporize into whatever you’re grilling. No more dry steak, chicken, or sausage.
You also get 635 square inches of primary cooking space, so you can effortlessly spread out your favorite foods without fuss or cramming. You can choose from liquid propane or natural gas as a fuel – there are grill models that can handle either option.
Still, when it comes time to put this grill in your cart, you might notice that it’s almost twice as expensive as the comparable Weber grill, which is why this one takes 2nd place next to the Weber Spirit E-310.
Weber Spirit E-310
The Weber Spirit E-310 brings the premium bells and whistles you’d expect from an entry-level Weber gas grill. With 529 square inches of cooking real estate, you have ample room to fire up your favorite porterhouse steaks and chicken burgers without packing or cramming unnecessarily.
There’s also a hefty 32,000 BTU output over three burners for plenty of heat distribution.
The combination of the stainless-steel burners and porcelain-enameled cast-iron cooking grate provides an evenly distributed grilling experience.
If you’re frustrated because your grill feels like a cheap toy instead of an efficient grilling tool, then the Weber Spirit E-310 might be your perfect grilling option.
The grill’s cook box and lid assembly come with a generous 10-year warranty that protects from rust-through and burn-through. So you can experiment with your best homestead cooking and grilling techniques while worrying less about the wear and tear of your grill.
Broil King vs Weber – Which Has the Better Entry-Level Gas Grill?
I fancy both gas grills from Broil King vs Weber! There are two main differences.
First, the Weber Spirit E-310 comes in a slightly smaller, tighter package. The Weber Spirit E-310 has 529 square inches of cooking space vs. 635 square inches for the Broil King Signet 320. However, it still comes with the necessities, such as a drip pan, tool hooks, and storage space underneath.
The Broil King Signet 320 also packs more of a punch with 40,000 BTUs vs. the Weber Spirit E-310’s 32,000 BTUs.
It’s also worth noting that, right now, the Broil King grill is much more expensive than the Weber, but by the time you read this, that might not be the case. Prices always change, and your mileage may vary!
Premium Grill Showdown #2 – Broil King, Baron 420 Pro vs Weber Genesis S-435
- Natural Gas Grill
- 460 square inches of cooking space
- 40,000 BTUs
- 145 pounds
- Stainless steel cooking grid
- Built-in lights for easy night-time cooking
- Stainless steel side shelves
- Close to perfect reviews from various sellers
- Large size with high power
- May be too large for some people
- Liquid propane gas grill
- 844 square-inches of cooking space
- 69,000 BTUs
- 176 pounds
- Extra-large sear zone
- Stainless steel side shelves
- One shelf lifts up for a side burner
- Perfect 5-star reviews across the board
- One of the biggest grills out there
- Great value for what you get
- Could be too large for some people
- Not a great investment for occasional grillers
Let’s also look at two of the premium gas grills from Broil King vs. Weber. Shall we?
To start, these grills have a few things in common. They both have the essentials, such as stainless steel side shelves, multiple burners, thermometers, and storage space. However, they have different features and primary burner sizes/BTU levels.
Broil King, Baron 420 Pro
Do you want Broil King’s ultimate performance grilling option? Then look no further than the Baron 420 Pro. This beefy, burly natural gas grill sports a generous 4,000 BTUs and 460 sq inches of cooking space. Plus, it comes with warming racks that offer a great amount of indirect heat.
It’s the perfect size for your next birthday party, holiday weekend, or get-together.
I also love the design of the tube burners on this grill. The burners light up your grill quickly and evenly, giving you great heat control. With 2-flames per burner, the stainless steel grill grates heat up almost immediately.
Whether you want a powerhouse grill or a lighter option, the Broil King Baron series can help. That’s because you can choose from a 3-burner model, a 4-burner model, or a 5-burner model.
The Baron 420 Pro is the 4-burner model, so you can go bigger or smaller. I don’t recommend the 5-burner model unless you grill for your entire family! You can likely get by with less grilling power if you’re a solo griller.
Another thing I adore about the Baron 420 grill is the style. You get to choose between stainless steel or a sleek black design. If you love grilling as much as I do, then presentation counts.
Additionally, one big reason to choose this grill is for its affordable price. While it has the cost of a premium grill, it’s much less expensive than many other options with similar features. All that, and almost perfect reviews! What’s not to love?
Weber Genesis S-435
If you wish to satiate the savage-like hunger of your ravenous dinner guests in record time, then the Weber Genesis II S-435 propane grill delivers – quickly!
The Weber Genesis II S-435 sports a massive 69,000 BTUs and four high-quality stainless steel burners. You also get a powerful searing station that can make short work of your burgers, hotdogs, sausages, shish kebabs, corn on the cob, or honey-glazed chicken. That extra burner is awesome for heating up veggies, warming food, or even searing.
The stainless steel cooking grids provide immaculate heat distribution, ideal for the perfectionist griller. Additionally, there’s an extra-large sear station with its own dial for fantastic heat control.
The Genesis II S-435 also has a fuel gauge, which is a nice feature! The fuel gauge only works if you use liquid propane.
You can also use natural gas fuel or liquid propane with this quality grill if you wish. Make sure to choose the correct grill model depending on which fuel option you want to use.
I forgot to mention that the Genesis II S-435 also has a ludicrously-massive 844 square inches of total cooking space. No more scrimping when grilling your jumbo shrimp, hotdogs, sausages, or veggie burgers.
Weber vs Broil King – Which Has the Better Premium High-End Gas Grill?
Both grills are excellent, and I grade either option with an A or better. If you want a smaller, lighter grill, go with the Broil King Baron 420 Pro. If you want the larger grilling option with more special features, snag the Weber Genesis S-435l. Neither option will disappoint you.
I love the size and extra features of the Broil King. The cooking surface also heats up fast. No more waiting for your succulently grilled steaks, burgers, and sausages.
I also love the size, power, and grace of the Weber Genesis II S-435. With 69,000 BTUs and 844 square inches of cooking real estate, this grill is a tank and a half – fit for feeding a legion.
I also think that Weber wins on the warranty front for their Genesis II series grills. The thing I appreciate about Weber is its warranty transparency.
Weber offers a 10-year warranty on all parts for their Genesis II line of grills without arguing or quibbling. They’re upfront about their warranty and proudly promote it on the grill’s product page.
Weber vs Broil King – Which One Should You Buy for Your Next BBQ?
I think that both Broil King vs Weber makes excellent choices for grilling enthusiasts regardless of the BBQ skill level or the griller’s style. Whether you want a small gas grill for your next barbeque or if you’re an industrial chef looking for a massive grilling machine, either brand can meet your grilling needs.
The main differences, I think, are the reviews and popularity. If real customer reviews are crucial to you, then Weber is the safer bet. But don’t take my word as gospel. I invite you to read the reviews. Look closely at the 5-star reviews for each manufacturer. Weber has a ton more reviews!
Even though I cherish the Broil King brand, this investigation has revealed that Weber is better than Broil King in terms of value, features, and customer service. You can’t go wrong with Weber if you demand the best American-made grills with stellar build quality and reviews.
If you don’t have the biggest budget for your next BBQ grill? Then you can’t go wrong with Broil King’s brand, either. Both brands get my stamp of approval.
Do You Agree?
Thank you for reading this Broil King vs Weber Grill comparison.
Please let us know what you think in the comments! Do you agree that Weber is slightly better than Broil King? Are they both equal? Or, maybe I’m wrong?!
I’d love to have your thoughts. Please let us know by commenting below!
More on Grilling and Backyard Cooking
Thursday 23rd of September 2021
Hey Elle, your blog is inspiring and info material I appreciate your effort, keep up the good work.
Friday 26th of March 2021
You should be ashamed of yourself for writing this article. I didn't even make it past the assembly portion. The majority of Weber grills are made in CHINA. Broil king grills with the exception of their pellet and keg are actually made in the US and Canada with the cast iron grates and less then a handful of parts sources from China. Broil King is still built to the standard Weber used to be.
Wednesday 7th of April 2021
Hey Cdubs! Yep, like I mentioned, Broil King grills are made in the US, with manufacturing locations in Dickson Tennessee, Huntington Indiana, and Waterloo Ontario. Most of the components are too, like their grill cook box, shelves, and steel carts.
Broil King themselves mention: "Our barbecue grill components are sourced with preference given to domestic suppliers whenever possible but do include some globally sourced components." So, we're pretty much made in the US, but not all of it...
Weber states: "Today, we stay true to our Midwestern roots by continuing to manufacture grills in Huntley, Illinois, using only the best U.S. and globally sourced components. All of our grills are designed and engineered by a team at our Chicago headquarters, and every day our wide assortment of grills roll off the manufacturing lines at our plant in Huntley, Illinois. This ensures our grills are built with the durability, workmanship and quality that matter to grillers. More importantly, it allows us to support our local community by keeping jobs here in Illinois — where it all started at Weber."
To me, this sounds like Broil Kind and Weber are very similar in their "we're made in the US but not all of it" statement?