Skip to Content

The Best Hay for Goats in Their Heyday. Or Any Day!

Goats eat everything! Right? Well, my herd of Dwarf Nigerian cross Boer goats doesn’t. Offer them organic lettuce fresh from the garden, and they’ll turn their collective noses up at it.

Offer them fresh oat hay, and they won’t even sniff it! Even some bales of alfalfa may prove too stalky for their delicate dispositions.

Admittedly, not all goats are as particular as mine, and while some may happily munch their way through a bale of straw, they won’t thrive on it. 

There are almost as many different hay varieties as there are goat breeds – that’s why finding the best hay is something of a challenge. 

The best hay for a lactating dairy goat won’t be the same as the best hay for mature bucks

dutch hybrid goats eating hay
Look at these adorable Dutch hybrid goats! I think they’re looking for lunch. Time for some fresh hay!

What Is the Best Hay for Goats?

Goats need good-quality grass hay that’s free from debris and mold. The actual type of grass doesn’t matter too much as long as it’s not too coarse for their tiny mouths. Many homesteaders buy Timothy hay for the main herd and alfalfa for their lactating does, who benefit from its higher protein and calcium content.

With hay prices soaring, it’s tempting to look for cheaper alternatives. You may even find yourself wondering, is straw or hay better for goats? Good-quality straw looks like hay and smells strangely appealing to humans, but goats know better. (They have more hay wisdom than us. For sure!) 

Hay is harvested and baled with the leaves and grains still attached, whereas straw is merely the collection of stalks left over after the grain harvesting.

As a result, it has almost no nutritional benefits, which is why goats generally prefer sleeping on it rather than eating it. 

However, there are different types of hay! That is probably where the confusion about straw comes from – the mix between hay and straw throws off even skillful farmers.

Not all hay is grass, after all, and you do get some types of cereal grain straw, as well as grass and legume hay. 

Cereal grain straw is more nutritious than the straw we use for bedding because, during harvest, the farmers leave the grain seeds still intact.

My goats aren’t that keen, and while they’ll nibble away at the oats, they’ll leave the stalks untouched.

Legume hays like alfalfa, vetch, and clover, have a higher protein content. They contain more of the nutrients goats need to stay healthy.

These are ideal for a pregnant and lactating doe and to give an under-nourished goat an energy boost, but they contain too much calcium and protein for the average adult goat.

Premium Goat Snacks!
Banana & Ginger Goat Snax
Get More Info
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
10/01/2022 02:06 am GMT

Timothy, brome, orchard grass, and bluegrass are all types of grass hay. Good-quality grass hay is both nutritional and digestible.

As long as it’s free of dust and mold and harvests early, it makes an excellent fodder. Harvested too late, it will be too stalky for a goat’s tiny mouth and more troublesome to digest.

Combining elements of both the above will keep your goats in excellent health.

Although we were feeding our lactating does some alfalfa, we found it was too dusty and fell apart too readily. 

More bale got trodden into the ground than consumed, making it expensive and futile. Pellet form would make a lot more sense, but are alfalfa pellets bad for goats? 

Are Alfalfa Pellets Bad for Goats?

If fed exclusively, alfalfa in any form can be bad for goats. Bucks, for example, are prone to developing urinary calculi, or stones in the urinary tract, if kept on an alfalfa-only diet for too long.

A better approach is to provide your entire herd with grass hay ad-lib and then mix some alfalfa pellets plus grain for your lactating does and anyone else that needs a bit extra. 

The calcium in alfalfa will increase milk production and, when fed alongside the phosphorus-rich grain, delivers the right balance of calcium and phosphorus. 

Read More – Raising Goats vs. Sheep! Which Is Best for Profits – and Fun?

What to Look for In a Bale of Hay

adorable baby goat munching on straw hat
I love this goat! Make sure to hold on to your hay and straw hats when you feed your goats! Otherwise, they might get the wrong idea.

You expect to find hay in any bale you buy, but I’ve found it’s often mixed up with a variety of other things. 

I’ve found mud, stones, weeds, plastic bags, and mold in my bales recently, all of which detract from its usefulness and nutritional value. These foreign bodies can also cause problems for your goats, despite their robust digestive systems. 

To establish which hay is the best for your goats, look for the following:

Leaf to Stalk Ratio in Your Hay

goat snacking on greens
Sometimes, goats demand more than just hay! I love to mix in a batch of greens, legumes, browse plants, and grass to keep the goats satisfied – and healthy.

The higher the leaf content, the more nutritious the hay.  

Smell of the Hay

A bale that smells sour or musty is probably moldy and therefore unappetizing – even for goats! 

Moldy hay can also cause listeriosis or Silage Sickness. Listeriosis is a potentially fatal infectious disease that causes encephalitis, blood poisoning, and abortion. (Yikes!)

Color of the Hay

When we see a bale of bright green hay, we get excited! It looks so good we might even consider eating it ourselves. Green bales indicate that it is still fresh. Fresh hay bales usually contain healthy levels of vitamins A and E. 

Hay that sits around for six months or more, or if it dwells in poor conditions, will usually have a yellow or brown hue. It will also lack the vitamin A and E levels of fresh hay.

Touch the Hay

Good-quality hay should be soft to the touch and flake easily. Not only will goats be reluctant to eat very stalky hay, but it’s also less nutritious.

Debris in the Hay

Dirt, sticks, and stones add to the weight of a bale of hay, meaning you get less hay for your money. A hale with lots of dirt in it will inevitably become dusty, potentially causing respiratory issues for your goats.

Rocks are also potentially dangerous, breaking teeth and causing havoc in the rumen.

Goat Vitamin Supplement!
Manna Pro Goat Mineral
Get More Info
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
10/01/2022 02:16 am GMT

Best Hay for Goats FAQ

baby goats resting next to hay inside barn
Growing goats love hay, too! I also try to supplement their goat diets with hay pellets to give them a delicious – and nutritious treat!

We have boatloads of experience feeding hay to goats and researching about goats!

That’s why we want to share a list of the top questions for any farmer with hungry goats to feed.

We hope you enjoy reading the answers!

What about you – and your goats?

Which hay do they prefer?

We’d love to hear about your experience!

Thanks for reading – and have a great day!

Read More – How Often Do You Have to Milk a Goat? Once or Twice a Day?


  • A horse-mad redhead with a passion for the outdoors, Nicky lives on a 6ha small-holding on the Wild Coast of South Africa. She spends her time rearing goats, riding (rearing) horses, and meticulously growing her own chicken food. She has a witch’s knack with herbs and supplements everything, from her beloved Australian Cattle Dog to the occasional passing zebra with the fruits of her labor. Nothing is bought unless Nicky fails to MacGyver it out of scraps of broken bridles, baling twine, or wire. She loves baling twine (and boxes, oddly enough).